See, it seems that this tax originated in the Senate... and we all know that ALL TAX BILLS MUST ORIGINATE IN THE HOUSE.
Right? And that's not what happened here. Is it?
Art 1, Sec 7 US Constitution
All bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills.
The reporter indicates that the House voted on the Senate bill, pulled from reconciliation, they "deemed" it "passed," so if the health care law is a tax (and the Supreme Court says it IS a tax) then it was not lawfully passed... hence, invalid.
Just sayin'.
3 comments:
Interesting thought, but I don't expect anything to come of it.
If nothing else, Obummer will just issue another Executive Order.
Haven't we already seen the constitution means nothing any longer?
Cool legal tactic - it could go to the Supreme Court. Oops...
Th e Supreme Court is no friend of the U.S.Constitution
Post a Comment